Pular para o conteúdo principal
Início

Análise, prevenção e aspectos associados.

Menu de conta de usuário

  • Entrar
Saiba mais
Cadastre-se
Fale conosco

Main menu

  • INÍCIO
  • NOTÍCIAS
  • ENCONTROS
  • FÓRUNS
  • BIBLIOTECA

Trilha de navegação

  • Início
  • Colisão de trens na Grécia e a atribuição de culpa que tenta evitar a prevenção

Colisão de trens na Grécia e a atribuição de culpa que tenta evitar a prevenção

Enviado por: ialmeida
em Qua, 01/03/2023 - 17:33

Colisão de trens na Grécia

Para variar fala de "autoridade"  culpa os trabalhadores e fecha os olhos às origens em profundidade de mais este desastre. 
A fala recebida do colega João Marcos Bernardes é esta pérola abaixo. 
""Everything in this tragedy points unfortunately, mainly to human error," Greek Prime Minister Kyriakos Mitsotakis said in a televised address on Wednesday."

No pior dos cenários o reducionismo da fala tenta esconder / dificultar que o ocorrido seja visto em perspectiva sistêmica que envolve pelo menos três sub-sistemas sócio-técnicos complexos em interação. As duas composições e o sistema de controle de tráfego. 
Para piorar a fala que atribui o evento a "erro humano" difunde a ideia de que o comportamento humano seria algo exclusivamente afeito ao ser humano. Mesmo que, ou apesar do fato de que cada um dos envolvidos estivesse em interação com um sistema técnico que embute tecnologia "de monte" e com os outros subsistemas. 
O incêndio que é citado como explicação para aumento do número de mortes no desastre é problema de segurança já abordado inclusive em desastres de trens do passado. A necessidade de construir composições com barreiras que atuem no sentido de minimizar chances de colisão, mas também barreiras que reduzam ameaças / perigos (qt de combustível), retardem enfim as chances de incêndios. Enfim, no caso, falharam as barreiras existentes (presumo que existiam porque sua falta "nesta altura do campeonato" seria algo praticamente criminoso) contra colisão e contra incêndio. 
 
Um desserviço á ideia de prevenção. 
Até a próxima

PB

Vejam link para notícia: 
Greece train crash kills at least 36 people, scores injured

By Alexandros Avramidis and Lefteris Papadimas 

  • Summary
  • Passenger, freight trains collide at high speed, at night
  • Trains were on the same track -regional governor
  • Some 350 people on passenger train; 2 crew on cargo train
  • Greece declares three days of national mourning

LARISSA, Greece, March 1 (Reuters) - At least 36 people were killed when a Greek passenger train collided head-on with a freight train late on Tuesday, derailing carriages which then burst into flames in the country's deadliest rail crash in living memory.

Many of the victims were thought to be university students returning home after a long holiday weekend and officials said the death toll was expected to rise further, as temperatures in one carriage had risen to 1,300 Celsius after it caught fire.

Authorities are working to establish how the high-speed passenger train collided with another carrying shipping containers, coming in the opposite direction and on the same track at speeds thought to be up to 160 km (100 miles) per hour.
"Everything in this tragedy points unfortunately, mainly to human error," Greek Prime Minister Kyriakos Mitsotakis said in a televised address on Wednesday.

Passengers described a "nightmarish" crash which shattered their train just before midnight near the central town of Larissa, some 200 miles north of Athens. It was headed to the northern city of Thessaloniki, from the Greek capital.

Many kicked through windows to escape the inferno, others were flung up to 40 metres on impact.

"There was panic ... the fire was immediate, as we were turning over we were being burned, fire was right and left," said Stergios Minenis, a 28-year-old who jumped to safety.

"Windows were being smashed and people were screaming ... One of the windows caved in from the impact of iron from the other train," another passenger, who escaped from the fifth carriage, told Skai TV:

A station master was arrested as investigators tried to work out why the two trains had been on the same track "for many kilometres", while the country's transport minister resigned.

As rescuers scoured the smouldering, mangled mass of steel in the morning, cranes lifted window-less carriages.

Fire brigade spokesman Vassilis Varthakogiannis said the temperatures in the first carriage made it hard to identify those trapped inside, or say how many died.

"The confirmed number of dead is 36 but based on these facts, and the findings from the scene of the tragedy, the number is expected to be greater."

Flags flew at half-staff in Athens, as well as in Brussels, in a tribute to the victims of the crash, as the government declared three days of national mourning.

"It's an unthinkable tragedy. Our thoughts today are with the relatives of the victims," Mitsotakis, the prime minister, said at the site of the crash, looking shattered.

In later statements he said he had accepted the resignations of senior officials in rail operator OSE and its subsidiary ERGOSE. In Athens, around 1,000 people protested outside the offices of Hellenic Train, another branch of the rail network, where some hurled stones at windows.

Police dispersed them with teargas.

In Larissa, where many victims of the crash had been taken, Nikos Makris sat on a pavement outside the hospital. His wife's sister was travelling in one of the first two carriages.

"She is missing. We have been waiting here since 2 a.m.," he told Reuters. "Now we are waiting to do a DNA test. We will be lucky to have a body to bury," he said.

Others were angry. The relative of one victim shouted: "Some bastard has to pay for this."

Transport Minister Kostas Karamanlis submitted his resignation, saying he was taking responsibility for the state's "long-standing failures" to fix a railway system he said was not fit for the 21st century.

The local station master, in charge of signalling, has been charged with causing mass deaths through negligence and causing grievous bodily harm through negligence, a police official said.

The 59-year-old man denied any responsibility, attributing the accident to a possible technical failure, the official said.

Yiannis Ditsas, head of the Greek railway workers union, told Skai TV that automatic signalling at the site of the crash had not been working.

There was no immediate official comment on this.

'MUM, I'M HURT'

The passenger train was carrying 342 travellers and 10 crew, with two crew on the cargo train, Hellenic Train data showed.

Sixty-six of those injured were hospitalised, six of whom were in intensive care, a fire brigade official said.

Survivors who did not need to be hospitalised were evacuated to Thessaloniki, where one woman ran to embrace her daughter as she disembarked from a bus.

"Mum don't, I'm hurt," the daughter said.

Another woman, who was waiting too, said her child was not picking up the phone.

Greece sold railway operator TRAINOSE to Italy's Ferrovie dello Stato Italiane in 2017 as part of its international bailout programme, expecting hundreds of millions of euros to be invested in rail infrastructure in the coming years.

The Italian division maintained responsibility for passenger and freight, while the Greek state-controlled OSE over infrastructure.

 

  • Efetue login ou registre-se para postar comentários

Visite nosso canal no Youtube
Fóruns

COVID-19

WebEncontros

Encontros
2025
Todos

 

Encontros
BIBLIOTECA
Destaques
Referências
PESQUISAS DO GRUPO
Pesquisas
Publicações
Em andamento
DECISÕES JUDICIAIS, PARECERES DE MINISTÉRIO PÚBLICO E TEMAS RELACIONADOS

Rodapé

  • Fale conosco
Licença Creative Commons      Projeto TCI Art      Sobre tema W3CSS
Desenvolvido com Drupal